Download the full report here.
A Fair Value Plan for legacy renewables could cut energy costs by £9.2bn over the next decade
Lower energy prices are fundamental to the economy and the energy transition: high electricity prices are holding back business, squeezing household budgets and weighing on growth.
Older wind and solar farms will receive £8.7bn next year: a subsidy that did its job 20 years ago has not kept pace with the economic pressures the country now faces.
A Fair Value Plan could save £9.2bn: paying these generators returns based on what they expected when they invested would cut costs by £3.8bn alone next year, with business the biggest winners.
The Fair Value Plan, published by the Energy Competitiveness Unit (ECU), hosted by non-profit research organisation Project Tempo, sets out how the Government’s proposed Wholesale Contract for Difference (WCfD) could be reformed to deliver real savings for billpayers while keeping investors’ trust.
High electricity prices have made British businesses less competitive, squeezed household spending and weighed on economic growth. They also reduce demand for electricity, which pushes up the cost of each unit of power and makes the energy transition harder. Reform is needed now rather than in a future crisis.
Older wind and solar farms are supported by the Renewables Obligation (RO), introduced in 2002 to encourage investment in what were then new and expensive technologies. The report says the RO achieved its objective but it has not kept pace with today’s economic context. In 2025/26, the RO added £102 to the average household bill. The Government has since moved 75% of that cost onto general taxation, but this shifts the cost from billpayers to taxpayers rather than reducing it.
In 2027, RO-supported wind and solar farms are expected to receive £8.7bn: £4.5bn in RO payments and £4.2bn from selling their power. This is driven by high wholesale prices following the Iran conflict, and by RO payments that have risen faster than the inflation investors expected when they invested.
The report proposes offering generators a single long-term Contract for Difference (CfD) at a fixed price, replacing both RO payments and wholesale revenue. The price would be based on the returns generators expected when they committed capital, removing wholesale income above what investors anticipated and inflation increases beyond what they expected. Generators would gain stronger protection than they have today through the CfD contract.
The ECU has been set up to develop and stress-test practical policies that government can adopt to make Britain’s energy system cheaper and more resilient while achieving decarbonisation. It aims to identify reforms that could cut annual system costs by £10bn by the end of the decade.